Rating: DNF Themes: Young Adult, Mystery, Thriller, Crime Thoughts: So disappointed. I loved the other two books and really loved Pip so to me this story was really a let down. There were small things such as Xanex in the UK, that nuts fit on bolts not screws and the medical/psychological treatment of PTSD aren't how we work in the real world really took me out of the story this time. Pip did not really feel like Pip at all this time (although I understand what Holly was trying to do) and the repetitions of it were a buy much. Also the trying to force a full circle thing was way to much for me, cheesy and I eye rolled in more than one instance at it.